{ "schema": "ecomark-automated-analysis-v4", "generated_at": "2026-08-30T12:50:07.970Z", "algorithm": { "version": "4", "status": "current", "name": "EcoMark v4", "published": "2026-08-28", "rubric": { "0": "Fails materially or creates clear harm in this criterion.", "1": "Poor. Significant problems or unnecessary impact remain.", "2": "Mixed. Some good practice is present, but material gaps remain.", "3": "Good. The criterion is mostly met with only limited gaps.", "4": "Strong. The criterion is deliberately and consistently met." }, "formula": { "criterion": "criterion_points = max_points × level ÷ 4", "category": "category_score = sum(criterion_points)", "overall": "overall_score = round(sum(category_score × category_weight))", "ranking": "competition ranking: equal scores share a rank and the next rank skips accordingly (1, 1, 3)", "comparison": "rankings compare assessments produced by the same EcoMark version only", "historical_cutoff": "historical rankings use published_at, not assessed_on" }, "analysis": { "type": "automated-observable-web", "rendered_homepage": true, "max_pages": 5, "max_policy_pages": 8, "max_asset_samples": 16, "freshness_hours": 24, "dns_record_types": [ "A", "AAAA", "CNAME", "MX", "NS", "TXT" ], "green_web_check": true, "rules": { "efficiency": { "payload": { "metric": "average_page_kb", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 500, 1000, 2000, 4000 ], "unit": "KB/page" }, "javascript": { "metric": "average_javascript_kb", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 100, 250, 500, 1000 ], "unit": "KB/page" }, "requests": { "metric": "average_resource_references", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 20, 40, 70, 100 ], "unit": "resources/page" }, "media": { "metric": "media_issue_count", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 1, 3, 6 ], "unit": "issues" }, "caching": { "metric": "cacheable_asset_percent", "direction": "higher", "bands": [ 80, 60, 40, 20 ], "unit": "%" } }, "privacy": { "trackers": { "metric": "tracker_count", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 1, 2, 4 ], "unit": "known trackers" }, "analytics": { "metric": "analytics_risk", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "unit": "risk level" }, "cookies": { "metric": "nonessential_cookie_count", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 1, 3, 6 ], "unit": "response cookies" }, "third_party_data": { "metric": "third_party_percent", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 10, 25, 50 ], "unit": "%" }, "invasive_techniques": { "metric": "invasive_tracker_count", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 0, 0, 1 ], "unit": "known invasive tools" } }, "sovereignty": { "provider_jurisdiction": { "metric": "us_provider_count", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 1, 3, 6 ], "unit": "visitor-facing provider ecosystems" }, "data_location": { "metric": "known_non_eu_data_percent", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 10, 30, 60 ], "unit": "%" }, "portability": { "metric": "proprietary_embed_count", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 1, 3, 6 ], "unit": "embeds" }, "concentration": { "metric": "top_provider_share_percent", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 40, 65, 85 ], "unit": "%" }, "openness": { "metric": "open_technology_score", "direction": "higher", "bands": [ 90, 75, 60, 40 ], "unit": "openness score" } }, "accessibility": { "semantics": { "metric": "semantic_issue_count", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 1, 2, 4 ], "unit": "issues" }, "keyboard": { "metric": "keyboard_issue_count", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 1, 3, 6 ], "unit": "issues" }, "controls": { "metric": "unlabelled_control_percent", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 5, 15, 30 ], "unit": "%" }, "visual": { "metric": "visual_issue_count", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 1, 2, 4 ], "unit": "issues" }, "resilience": { "metric": "raw_text_ratio_percent", "direction": "higher", "bands": [ 80, 60, 40, 20 ], "unit": "%" } }, "responsibility": { "transparency": { "metric": "transparency_evidence_score", "direction": "higher", "bands": [ 90, 75, 55, 35 ], "unit": "evidence score" }, "security": { "metric": "security_header_score", "direction": "higher", "bands": [ 100, 83, 67, 50 ], "unit": "% basic browser protections" }, "consent_design": { "metric": "consent_issue_score", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "unit": "risk level" }, "supplier_disclosure": { "metric": "undisclosed_provider_percent", "direction": "lower", "bands": [ 0, 25, 50, 75 ], "unit": "%" }, "sustainability_governance": { "metric": "sustainability_evidence_score", "direction": "higher", "bands": [ 4, 3, 2, 1 ], "unit": "evidence signals" } } }, "note": "EcoMark v4 expands the observable evidence sample to five connected pages, actively checks common policy and sitemap paths, validates six basic browser security protections and records lightweight PageSpeed-style diagnostics. It does not call Google PageSpeed Insights and does not claim Core Web Vitals field data.", "max_common_path_probes": 20, "pagespeed_style_checks": true, "security_header_checks": 6 }, "grades": [ { "grade": "A", "min": 90, "max": 100 }, { "grade": "B", "min": 80, "max": 89 }, { "grade": "C", "min": 70, "max": 79 }, { "grade": "D", "min": 60, "max": 69 }, { "grade": "E", "min": 50, "max": 59 }, { "grade": "F", "min": 0, "max": 49 } ], "categories": [ { "key": "efficiency", "label": "Efficiency", "weight": 0.25, "short": "Resource use, page weight and avoidable computation.", "criteria": [ { "key": "payload", "label": "Payload", "max_points": 20, "description": "Measured HTML and sampled asset payload is proportionate and optimised." }, { "key": "javascript", "label": "JavaScript", "max_points": 20, "description": "Referenced JavaScript weight is kept proportionate." }, { "key": "requests", "label": "Requests", "max_points": 20, "description": "Pages avoid excessive resource references and third-party connections." }, { "key": "media", "label": "Media", "max_points": 20, "description": "Images and video avoid obvious loading and autoplay waste." }, { "key": "caching", "label": "Caching and compression", "max_points": 20, "description": "Sampled static assets expose effective cache policy." } ] }, { "key": "privacy", "label": "Privacy", "weight": 0.25, "short": "Tracking, cookies, profiling, analytics and consent.", "criteria": [ { "key": "trackers", "label": "Behavioural tracking", "max_points": 20, "description": "Known advertising pixels and cross-site trackers are absent or minimised." }, { "key": "analytics", "label": "Analytics minimisation", "max_points": 20, "description": "Analytics technology is absent or privacy-preserving and proportionate." }, { "key": "cookies", "label": "Cookies and consent", "max_points": 20, "description": "Non-essential response cookies are avoided before interaction." }, { "key": "third_party_data", "label": "Third-party disclosure", "max_points": 20, "description": "Resource loading does not unnecessarily disclose visits to third parties." }, { "key": "invasive_techniques", "label": "Invasive techniques", "max_points": 20, "description": "Known session replay and similarly invasive tools are absent." } ] }, { "key": "sovereignty", "label": "Sovereignty", "weight": 0.2, "short": "Ownership, geography, openness, portability and dependency.", "criteria": [ { "key": "provider_jurisdiction", "label": "Provider jurisdiction", "max_points": 20, "description": "Observable visitor-facing dependencies minimise reliance on US-headquartered platform ecosystems." }, { "key": "data_location", "label": "Third-party geography", "max_points": 20, "description": "Known non-EU third-party data exposure is minimised." }, { "key": "portability", "label": "Portable delivery", "max_points": 20, "description": "Pages minimise proprietary embeds and platform-specific content dependencies." }, { "key": "concentration", "label": "Supplier concentration", "max_points": 20, "description": "Third-party resource loading is not dominated by one provider ecosystem." }, { "key": "openness", "label": "Open technology", "max_points": 20, "description": "Open standards, first-party delivery, open-source technology and public source code are preferred where practical." } ] }, { "key": "accessibility", "label": "Accessibility", "weight": 0.15, "short": "Inclusive, semantic and resilient implementation.", "criteria": [ { "key": "semantics", "label": "Semantics", "max_points": 20, "description": "HTML exposes basic language, heading and landmark structure." }, { "key": "keyboard", "label": "Keyboard access", "max_points": 20, "description": "Markup avoids obvious keyboard-hostile interaction patterns." }, { "key": "controls", "label": "Forms and controls", "max_points": 20, "description": "Form controls expose labels or accessible names." }, { "key": "visual", "label": "Visual accessibility", "max_points": 20, "description": "Viewport and media markup avoid obvious visual accessibility barriers." }, { "key": "resilience", "label": "Resilience", "max_points": 20, "description": "Meaningful text remains present without relying entirely on client rendering." } ] }, { "key": "responsibility", "label": "Responsibility", "weight": 0.15, "short": "Transparency, security basics and responsible choices.", "criteria": [ { "key": "transparency", "label": "Public accountability", "max_points": 20, "description": "Privacy, terms, accessibility, contact and applicable registration information are discoverable." }, { "key": "security", "label": "Security basics", "max_points": 20, "description": "The main response exposes sensible browser security headers." }, { "key": "consent_design", "label": "Consent design", "max_points": 20, "description": "Tracking and consent markup avoids obvious one-sided choice patterns." }, { "key": "supplier_disclosure", "label": "Supplier disclosure", "max_points": 20, "description": "Detected material visitor-facing providers are reflected in discoverable privacy information." }, { "key": "sustainability_governance", "label": "Sustainability evidence", "max_points": 20, "description": "Green hosting, carbon.txt and public sustainability information provide discoverable evidence of digital sustainability practice." } ] } ] }, "algorithm_sha256": "fd7b59cbb2964a4f059df0645f095f1695a2d85bfcf776dc0d88da6f174781a4", "source_fingerprint": "ea18349b11082d1116b5c22aafe6213686a6fd1306d3bcd84981505e87171d9c", "external_sources": { "dns": "Cloudflare 1.1.1.1 DNS over HTTPS", "green_hosting": "Green Web Foundation Greencheck API", "performance": "EcoMark lightweight lab diagnostics; no Google PageSpeed API call" }, "metrics": { "pages_checked": 5, "browser_rendered_homepage": false, "average_page_kb": 620, "average_javascript_kb": 0, "average_resource_references": 101, "media_issue_count": 148, "cacheable_asset_percent": 90, "tracker_count": 0, "analytics_risk": 0, "nonessential_cookie_count": 0, "third_party_percent": 90, "invasive_tracker_count": 0, "us_provider_count": 1, "known_non_eu_data_percent": 0, "proprietary_embed_count": 0, "top_provider_share_percent": 100, "first_party_asset_percent": 10, "semantic_issue_count": 0, "keyboard_issue_count": 0, "unlabelled_control_percent": 0, "visual_issue_count": 0, "raw_text_ratio_percent": 100, "missing_transparency_links": 2, "security_header_count": 5, "consent_issue_score": 0, "undisclosed_provider_percent": 0, "responsible_default_issue_count": 0, "dns_record_count": 16, "policy_pages_discovered": 5, "common_path_probe_count": 13, "sitemap_count": 1, "legal_identifier_count": 0, "public_source_repository": false, "open_source_technology_count": 1, "open_technology_score": 68, "transparency_evidence_score": 72, "sustainability_evidence_score": 0, "green_hosting_verified": false, "carbon_txt_found": false, "security_header_score": 83, "page_speed_checks_passed": 5, "page_speed_checks_total": 7, "homepage_response_ms": 41, "render_blocking_candidate_count": 2, "images_without_dimensions": 0 }, "analysis_quality": { "status": "good", "browser_result": "blocked-or-incomplete; static fallback used", "raw_homepage_status": 200, "raw_homepage_text_chars": 12519, "raw_homepage_resources": 130, "raw_homepage_response_ms": 41 }, "pages": [ { "url": "https://proton.me/", "status": 200, "browser_rendered": false, "html_bytes": 444908 }, { "url": "https://proton.me/about", "status": 200, "browser_rendered": false, "html_bytes": 309651 }, { "url": "https://proton.me/about/impact", "status": 200, "browser_rendered": false, "html_bytes": 905922 }, { "url": "https://proton.me/about/team", "status": 200, "browser_rendered": false, "html_bytes": 435581 }, { "url": "https://proton.me/support/contact-product", "status": 200, "browser_rendered": false, "html_bytes": 338674 } ], "documents": { "about": { "url": "https://proton.me/about", "reachable": true, "source": "linked", "blocked_by_robots": false }, "contact": { "url": "https://proton.me/support/contact-product", "reachable": true, "source": "linked", "blocked_by_robots": false }, "privacy": { "url": "https://proton.me/blog/privacy-ecosystem", "reachable": true, "source": "linked", "blocked_by_robots": false }, "terms": { "url": "https://proton.me/legal/terms", "reachable": true, "source": "linked", "blocked_by_robots": false }, "legal": { "url": "https://proton.me/legal/transparency", "reachable": true, "source": "linked", "blocked_by_robots": false } }, "document_probes": [ { "kind": "cookies", "url": "https://proton.me/cookies", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "cookies", "url": "https://proton.me/cookie-policy", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "cookies", "url": "https://proton.me/cookiepolicy", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "cookies", "url": "https://proton.me/cookie_policy", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "cookies", "url": "https://proton.me/cookies-policy", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "cookies", "url": "https://proton.me/cookie-notice", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "accessibility", "url": "https://proton.me/accessibility", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "accessibility", "url": "https://proton.me/accessibility-statement", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "accessibility", "url": "https://proton.me/accessibility_statement", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "sustainability", "url": "https://proton.me/sustainability", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "sustainability", "url": "https://proton.me/environment", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "sustainability", "url": "https://proton.me/climate", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "kind": "sustainability", "url": "https://proton.me/carbon", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false } ], "sitemaps": { "found": [ "https://proton.me/sitemap.xml" ], "checked": [ { "url": "https://proton.me/sitemap.xml", "reachable": true, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "url": "https://proton.me/sitemap_index.xml", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "url": "https://proton.me/sitemap-index.xml", "reachable": false, "blocked_by_robots": false }, { "url": "https://proton.me/sitemap.xml", "reachable": true, "blocked_by_robots": false } ] }, "legal_identifiers": [], "dns": { "records": { "A": [ "185.70.42.45" ], "AAAA": [], "CNAME": [], "MX": [ "10 mail.protonmail.ch", "20 mailsec.protonmail.ch" ], "NS": [ "ns1.proton.me", "ns2.proton.me", "ns3.proton.me" ], "TXT": [ "yandex-verification: 95a7888a0f987e6a", "v=spf1 include:_spf.protonmail.ch ~all", "linkedin-site-verification=01e79150-bf68-4e0c-ad04-822dc1015b3b", "protonmail-verification=5262a92f988e64f1be1362138befdf1e19d6a4c1", "google-site-verification=2FGIDo-Gf-lWE6t_gWd9gpPTehHD85hbNiEujPVgysc", "google-site-verification=4UIZgETX8lGnv0WwpeJJbszo9daKOdXXYBKCA2XLf94", "google-site-verification=MUjtKY-4uQAjE92Z2-s1nm9m4mvdqY2z6HCvi_Bj4so", "google-site-verification=QviHfE1VQ57-tDmDLxM6BQH1mdgvdQ_0QsIvCht2IaU", "google-site-verification=_ayl1WqWIag2WkIbK4sNg_x3NCT5nYOl_DgtFPTYKeg", "zoom-domain-verification=ZOOM_verify_5990c1fbb09d4c6aba062cded6cbdf06" ], "WWW_CNAME": [] }, "record_count": 16, "carbon_txt_location": null }, "security_headers": { "score": 83, "passed": 5, "total": 6, "checks": [ { "key": "hsts", "label": "HSTS", "pass": true, "value": "max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload" }, { "key": "csp", "label": "Content Security Policy", "pass": true, "value": "default-src 'self'; media-src https://static.zdassets.com https://res.cloudinary.com https://pmecdn.protonweb.com; connect-src 'self' wss: https://protonmail.zendesk.com https://ekr.zdassets.com blob: https://account.proton.me https://reports.proton.me https://telemetry.proton.me https://*.algolia.net https://*.algolianet.com https://go.getproton.me https://noembed.com https://boards-api.greenhouse.io https://proton.me https://*.paypal.com https://*.paypalobjects.com https://growth.proton.me ; script-src 'self' blob: 'unsafe-eval' 'unsafe-inline' https://static.zdassets.com https://pmecdn.protonweb.com https://www.youtube.com https://platform.twitter.com https://*.paypal.com https://*.paypalobjects.com; style-src 'self' 'unsafe-inline' https://pmecdn.protonweb.com https://*.paypal.com https://*.paypalobjects.com; font-src 'self' https://pmecdn.protonweb.com; img-src 'self' data: blob: https:; frame-src 'self' data: blob: https://www.youtube-nocookie.com https://platform.twitter.com https://*.paypal.com https://*.paypalobjects.com; object-src 'self' data: blob:; child-src 'self' data: blob: https://*.paypal.com https://*.paypalobjects.com; report-uri https://reports.proton.me/reports/csp; frame-ancestors 'self' https://*.proton.me;" }, { "key": "nosniff", "label": "X-Content-Type-Options", "pass": true, "value": "nosniff" }, { "key": "referrer", "label": "Referrer-Policy", "pass": true, "value": "strict-origin-when-cross-origin" }, { "key": "permissions", "label": "Permissions-Policy", "pass": false, "value": null }, { "key": "framing", "label": "Frame protection", "pass": true, "value": "CSP frame-ancestors" } ], "missing": [ "Permissions-Policy" ] }, "performance_diagnostics": { "kind": "lightweight-lab-proxy", "note": "These are EcoMark diagnostics inspired by common PageSpeed/Lighthouse checks. They are not a Google PageSpeed score and do not claim CrUX or Core Web Vitals field data.", "html_kb": 434, "response_ms": 41, "render_blocking_script_candidates": 0, "render_blocking_stylesheet_candidates": 2, "images_without_dimensions": 0, "images_without_lazy": 45, "passed": 5, "total": 7, "checks": [ { "key": "response", "label": "Initial response under 800 ms from EcoMark", "pass": true, "value": "41 ms" }, { "key": "payload", "label": "Measured page under 1 MB", "pass": true, "value": "620 KB/page" }, { "key": "javascript", "label": "JavaScript under 250 KB/page", "pass": true, "value": "0 KB/page" }, { "key": "requests", "label": "Fewer than 40 resource references/page", "pass": false, "value": "101 references/page" }, { "key": "caching", "label": "At least 60% of sampled assets cacheable", "pass": true, "value": "90%" }, { "key": "render_blocking", "label": "No obvious parser/render-blocking candidates", "pass": false, "value": "2 candidates" }, { "key": "image_dimensions", "label": "Images include width and height", "pass": true, "value": "0 missing dimensions" } ] }, "open_technologies": [ "Astro" ], "source_repository": null, "green_web": { "checked": true, "green": false, "hosted_by": null, "supporting_documents": [] }, "carbon_txt": { "found": false, "method": null, "location": null }, "providers": [], "tracker_urls": [], "assessment": { "id": "69e2061e-9988-4825-9b2d-500bae6d348c", "domain": "proton.me", "site_name": "Proton: Privacy by default", "website_url": "https://proton.me/", "ecomark_version": "4", "overall_score": 72, "grade": "C", "summary": "Automated EcoMark v4 approximation using up to 5 connected pages, DNS, active policy/sitemap discovery, browser security checks and lightweight performance diagnostics. Browser Run was blocked or incomplete, so the normal public HTML response was used instead. Analysis quality: good.", "assessed_on": "2026-08-30", "categories": [ { "category": "efficiency", "score": 55, "criteria": { "payload": { "level": 3, "points": 15 }, "javascript": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "requests": { "level": 0, "points": 0 }, "media": { "level": 0, "points": 0 }, "caching": { "level": 4, "points": 20 } }, "priority": "high", "finding": "5 connected pages · ~620 KB measured/page · 0 KB JavaScript/page · 101 resource references/page · 90% sampled assets cacheable. PageSpeed-style checks: 5/7; 2 obvious blocking candidates; 0 images without width/height.", "evidence": "5 connected pages · ~620 KB measured/page · 0 KB JavaScript/page · 101 resource references/page · 90% sampled assets cacheable. PageSpeed-style checks: 5/7; 2 obvious blocking candidates; 0 images without width/height.", "why_it_matters": "Lighter pages consume less bandwidth and device work and remain usable on slower connections.", "action": "Reduce resource and third-party requests by consolidating assets and removing unnecessary integrations." }, { "category": "privacy", "score": 80, "criteria": { "trackers": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "analytics": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "cookies": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "third_party_data": { "level": 0, "points": 0 }, "invasive_techniques": { "level": 4, "points": 20 } }, "priority": "low", "finding": "0 known trackers · 0 tracking-style response cookies · 90% third-party resource references.", "evidence": "0 known trackers · 0 tracking-style response cookies · 90% third-party resource references.", "why_it_matters": "Minimising tracking and third-party disclosure reduces profiling and unnecessary visitor data exposure.", "action": "Move commonly used assets and services first-party where practical." }, { "category": "sovereignty", "score": 65, "criteria": { "provider_jurisdiction": { "level": 3, "points": 15 }, "data_location": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "portability": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "concentration": { "level": 0, "points": 0 }, "openness": { "level": 2, "points": 10 } }, "priority": "medium", "finding": "1 US-headquartered visitor-facing provider ecosystems · 10% first-party assets · open technology 68/100 · Astro. DNS: NS ns1.proton.me, ns2.proton.me · MX 10 mail.protonmail.ch, 20 mailsec.protonmail.ch.", "evidence": "1 US-headquartered visitor-facing provider ecosystems · 10% first-party assets · open technology 68/100 · Astro. DNS: NS ns1.proton.me, ns2.proton.me · MX 10 mail.protonmail.ch, 20 mailsec.protonmail.ch.", "why_it_matters": "A more portable and less concentrated stack gives organisations more control over technology and jurisdiction.", "action": "Avoid concentrating most third-party delivery in one provider ecosystem." }, { "category": "accessibility", "score": 100, "criteria": { "semantics": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "keyboard": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "controls": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "visual": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "resilience": { "level": 4, "points": 20 } }, "priority": "low", "finding": "0 semantic issues · 0 keyboard markup issues · 0% unlabelled controls · 100% raw/rendered text ratio.", "evidence": "0 semantic issues · 0 keyboard markup issues · 0% unlabelled controls · 100% raw/rendered text ratio.", "why_it_matters": "Accessible, resilient markup works for more people, assistive technology and older or constrained devices.", "action": "No material issue was detected in this category. Maintain the current practice and re-run EcoMark after material website changes." }, { "category": "responsibility", "score": 65, "criteria": { "transparency": { "level": 2, "points": 10 }, "security": { "level": 3, "points": 15 }, "consent_design": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "supplier_disclosure": { "level": 4, "points": 20 }, "sustainability_governance": { "level": 0, "points": 0 } }, "priority": "medium", "finding": "Privacy ✓ · Cookies n/a · Terms ✓ · Accessibility ✗ · Contact/About ✓. Public registration IDs: none detected. no verified green-hosting evidence found. carbon.txt ✗ · sitemap ✓ · security 5/6. Missing: Permissions-Policy.", "evidence": "Privacy ✓ · Cookies n/a · Terms ✓ · Accessibility ✗ · Contact/About ✓. Public registration IDs: none detected. no verified green-hosting evidence found. carbon.txt ✗ · sitemap ✓ · security 5/6. Missing: Permissions-Policy.", "why_it_matters": "Transparent, secure defaults make digital impact understandable and give visitors meaningful choices.", "action": "Publish sustainability evidence, consider carbon.txt, and use independently verified green hosting where practical." } ] } }